Switching Payroll Companies: How to Make a Smooth Transition

Many small business owners consider changing payroll providers due to issues like poor customer support, hidden fees, outdated tech, or systems that just don’t scale with a growing business.  

Whether you're managing payroll on your own or unhappy with your current provider, you may be wondering: How difficult is it to switch payroll companies?

With good support and a clear plan, switching payroll providers can be easier than you think.

This guide walks you through how to switch payroll providers with confidence—from deciding when to make the move, to a step-by-step breakdown, a checklist, and common mistakes to avoid.  

You’ll also learn why thousands of small business owners have trusted SurePayroll® by Paychex to make the transition seamless.

Why Businesses Consider Switching Payroll Providers

A new payroll solution might be the right move if:

Payroll errors are costing you time and money.
Mistakes in payroll tax filings, late submissions, or inaccurate payroll processing can result in penalties and stress you don’t need.

Your current provider has hidden fees or unpredictable costs.
Extra charges for off-cycle payrolls or basic features can make budgeting difficult.

Customer service is lacking.
If you can’t reach a human or get the online support you need when issues arise, it may be time to switch.

Your business is growing, but your payroll solution isn’t.
Adding employees or managing multiple pay rates shouldn’t require hours of manual work. Look for time-saving features like employee portals, direct deposit, and integration with accounting software.

The system is just hard to use.
Payroll software should be intuitive, quick to learn, and accessible anywhere.

You need HR or employee benefits support.
Choosing a provider that offers services like 401(k) plans, health benefits, and HR guidance can help you grow with confidence.

When Is the Best Time to Switch Payroll Providers?

Many small business owners think they can only switch at the start of the year—but that’s a myth.

The truth is, switching payroll providers can happen any time that works best for your business. That said, some times of year are easier than others.

Best times to switch payroll companies:

• Start of the year: Switching in January offers the cleanest break. Your new provider can handle tax filings for the full year, with no need to transfer historical data.

• End of a quarter: This is another good option. It allows you to align your first payroll run with a new reporting period.

Things to consider if switching outside of these windows:

• You may need to transfer year-to-date employee pay history and tax data from your current system.

• There could be more setup steps involved to help ensure accurate payroll processing and tax filings.

With the right provider, this transition can be smooth. You can get expert help gathering the data, setting up your new system, and running payroll without disruption.

Read our guide on how to choose a payroll service that fits your business.  

Switching Payroll Companies Mid-Year: What You Need to Know

Can you switch payroll providers mid-year? Yes. It just takes a little extra planning.

Here’s what to expect:

What You’ll Need

To switch providers mid-year, be prepared to provide:

• Year-to-date payroll reports

• Employee pay and tax information

• Copies of recent payroll tax filings

• Employee forms (W-4, state withholding, direct deposit, etc.)

• Records of deductions (benefits, garnishments, etc.)

Pitfalls to Avoid

• Not transferring complete year-to-date data

• Overlooking tax filing responsibilities during the transition

• Switching before your new system is fully set up

A well-prepared provider will be able to walk you through every step. SurePayroll offers free onboarding support that includes payroll history migration and guidance on your first payroll run.

Step-by-Step Guide to Switching Payroll Companies

If you're wondering how to switch payroll providers smoothly, here’s your roadmap. These six steps can help set up a seamless transition with minimal disruption.

Step 1: Evaluate Your Current Payroll Contract

Before switching, review your current contract for:

• Termination clauses

• Required notice periods

• Early termination fees

It’s important to time your switch correctly to avoid unnecessary charges or service overlap.

Step 2: Research and Choose a New Provider

Look for a provider that meets both your current needs and future goals. Prioritize features such as:

• Automated payroll, tax calculations, and tax filing

• Direct deposit and unlimited payroll runs

• New hire reporting

• Employee self-service portal with access to online pay stubs

• Integrations with time-tracking and accounting software

• Encryption and firewalls to protect sensitive data

Also consider:

• Pricing and any add-ons

• Scalable plans as your team grows

• Responsive, accessible support

It’s also a good idea to read reviews on Capterra or Trustpilot. You can also ask for a product demo.

Step 3: Prepare Necessary Payroll Data

Gather the documents and details your new provider will need to set up your account. That includes:

Business info:

• Legal business name and address

• Federal Employee Identification Number (FEIN) and state tax IDs

• SUI (state unemployment insurance) rates

Employee info:

• Names, addresses, Social Security numbers

• Form W-4, Employee Withholding Certificate, and state withholding forms

• Direct deposit info

• Any benefits or deduction details

Payroll specifics:

• Current pay schedule and pay periods

• Pay history and tax deposit records

• Year-to-date payroll and tax forms

Accuracy matters—this step is key to avoiding issues or delays.

Step 4: Inform Key Stakeholders and Employees

Communicate the switch early and clearly by notifying employees. Let your team know:

• Why you're changing payroll providers

• If anything will change in how/when they’re paid

• What actions (if any) they need to take

Being proactive can help build trust and reduce confusion.

Step 5: Set Up and Test Your New Payroll System

Work with your new provider to complete onboarding:

• Set up your payroll schedule

• Enter all employee and tax data

• Enable features like direct deposit, auto payroll, and new hire reporting

Before your first official payroll run, do a trial run to check for accuracy.

Step 6: Confirm Payroll Accuracy

Once your first payroll is processed:

• Review employee pay for accuracy

• Confirm tax filings were submitted correctly

• Check that your reports match your records

Switching Payroll Companies Checklist

Use this checklist to simplify the process of switching payroll providers and help make sure nothing slips through the cracks.

Evaluate your current provider

• Review your contract for termination terms

• Confirm notice period or fees

• Determine ideal timing for your switch

Choose a new payroll provider

• Compare features, support, and scalability

• Look for automation, integrations, and tax filing services

• Ask for a product demo and review pricing

Gather payroll and employee data

• Business info (EIN, tax IDs, SUI rates)

• Employee info (W-4s, direct deposit details)

• Year-to-date payroll and tax records

Communicate with your team

• Let employees know about the switch

• Clarify what, if anything, they need to do

• Set expectations for any changes

Set up and test your new payroll system

• Complete onboarding with your new provider

• Input data and confirm accuracy

• Run a test payroll if possible

Verify accuracy

• Review first pay run

• Confirm tax filings

• Ensure payroll reports match your records

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Switching Payroll Providers

Even the best plans can hit bumps. Here’s how to help avoid common pitfalls when switching payroll companies:

Missing data or incomplete records
Failing to transfer year-to-date employee info or tax forms can lead to pay issues and filing errors.

Not reviewing provider contract terms
Skipping this step may result in unexpected fees or service disruptions.

Overlooking accuracy checks
Make sure your new provider handles filings properly and in accordance with federal, state, and local requirements.

Rushing the setup process
Take the time to test the system and review reports before your first payroll run.

Poor communication with employees
Failing to inform your team can cause unnecessary confusion or concern.

Thoughtful planning and onboarding support can help manage these issues so switching can be a smooth and easy experience.

‍
Conclusion: Why SurePayroll Makes Switching Easy

You didn’t start your business to manage payroll—but we did.

At SurePayroll, we help small business owners simplify the complexities of payroll and payroll tax management. Whether you're switching from another company or from doing it yourself, our team is with you every step of the way.

Here’s what you can expect when you switch to SurePayroll:

• Dedicated onboarding specialists

• Help gathering and migrating your payroll history

• Free unlimited payroll runs

• Free direct deposit and auto payroll

• Automatic payroll tax calculations, filing, and deposits

• Fast, flexible customer support

If you’re ready to simplify payroll, you’re ready to switch to SurePayroll.